Travel With a Tour Group vs Travel Planning On Your Own

August 29, 2023 | Travel Planning , Travelling Alone

The view from above Eagle’s Nest. Click for video.

Magnificent. The view from the top of Eagle’s Nest, Germany.

You can walk quite high up the mountain, and you do feel the difference in the air you breathe. An interesting piece of history but the views are the star attraction here. From as high as I hiked, I had about a 300 degree view of the alps, including HockKalter, Berchtesgadener Hochthron, and Salzburger Hochthron peaks.  

The question is, how do you get there? 

With a tour group or plan your own itinerary? 

There are benefits to both ways to travel, and drawbacks to both as well.

My last vacation was divided into 2 main parts: A 10-day tour of Imperial Europe; and 18 days planned by myself. There are important things to consider and compare.

PLANNING TIME

I had a rough idea of where I wanted to go, so I read a bunch of various tours and itineraries, from a couple tour companies. Did some research on the tours available. Selected a tour.  Picked the departure date. I called and booked my tour through the company directly.  I made sure I had the documents required. And that was it. Done. I did do some research on the cities we would visit, and I made a list of a few places I wanted to check out during downtime, but that is not required. All I had to do was get my butt to Munich on time. Total planning time: 8 hours.  

Planning my own itinerary was a true process. I couldn’t tell you how many hours it took.  Well north of 100. I did have a couple fixed dates with a lot of flexibility in my vacation, so the research to maximize my time was extensive. Build your itinerary around the fixed dates on your calendar.   Great planning ideas often became logistical impossibilities, I was always making sure travel plans were actually possible. Not just possible, but truly feasible. 

SCHEDULE FREEDOM

Someone else did all the planning. ‘Be on time!’ was my only responsibility.

When travelling with a tour group, you don’t have a lot of free time. Your itinerary is locked in, and you have very little control over where you stay and what you’ll see. If you go on the elective excursions, you will have very little free time. If you do not go on the excursions, you will have some free time, but always within the confines of the main tour itinerary.

When you make your own itinerary, you are only confined by your imagination.  You decide the places, dates, and times of your adventure. You have the freedom to craft an adventure based entirely on your own goals and interests!! Put a couple of truly important-to-you dates on your itinerary, and work from there.                

Remember: Complete Freedom also comes with Complete Responsibility!!

The first cost of schedule freedom is the time you have to put into planning your adventure. The second cost of schedule freedom is responsibility.  It’s your plan. It’s on you. Everything. So be organized and have a backup plan for when plan A falls apart unexpectedly.  
The freedom of your own schedule is still constrained by transportation schedules, accommodation availability, and your budget.

CAREFREE TRAVEL

This is largely a question of responsibility.  When I was on my tour, my most important responsibility was getting my lazy self out of bed on time to make the bus. Seriously. That was it. “Be on time for the bus!” was my biggest responsibility. I had zero cares, and thoroughly enjoyed that aspect of the tour. It was truly wonderful, and added an unexpected dimension to my vacation. The lack of responsibility helped me to relax, and really enjoy the tour.  

When the tour part of my vacation was over, my stress level immediately increased. Suddenly I was responsible for my own travel. Tickets? Check. Transportation? Check. Travel Documents? Check. Are the tickets on an app or paper? Which station do I catch the train from?  Which tram stop do I get off for the Rijksmuseum? My vacation was filled with questions, and I did not always have the answers. Technology has certainly helped the traveler. Google maps and all the various apps available have made it easier to travel and stay organized.  But it’s still on you.

Hungarian Parliament, Budapest. A very busy attraction, be there when it opens!

ADVANCE ENTRY TO POPULAR SITES

On my tour we had many early morning alarms, but for good reason.  By arriving to popular tourist locations early, often 15 minutes before opening, our group did not deal with the crowds that would be forming outside as we left. A considerable advantage.  Our guides were never rushed or pressed for time, and we were able to ask questions and learn more details about the places we visited. When we went to Eagle’s nest, there was no one but our tour group on the first buses up the mountain. When we returned to the base of the mountain, the crowds were huge and lines were long. 

When planning your own itinerary, that sort of advance entry is difficult to organize. You will need to check with private tour operators, local guides and the location itself. Time of day matters when visiting popular tourist sites. The more you are able to take advantage of advance entry opportunities, the more time you have to enjoy the attraction you are visiting. 

MEETING PEOPLE FROM AROUND THE WORLD

While the lack of responsibility was very nice and relaxing, it was not the best thing about taking my organized tour.  The best thing about my tour was meeting people from all over the globe. I was the lone Canadian in the group. Five American states were represented, and there were a bunch of Australians from different parts of that country. A few other countries were represented.  The only thing we all had in common was speaking English. 

It was truly wonderful to break bread and talk to people I never would have talked to otherwise. Many issues in different parts of the world are very close to issues at home. Talking to an Australian school teacher was like talking to my mother, also a teacher. I talked to the Australians about their ongoing aboriginal issues, as we in Canada deal with the horrific residential school system. Two of the Australians were forest fire fighters, and had been to Canada to help with the devastating Fort Mcmurray fire.  

There was a woman who was born in Iran but escaped in her early twenties. She went to jail twice as a student, for dyeing her hair and painting her fingernails. I had heard that this sort of thing happened, but never talked to someone who lived through it. 

There was a wonderful family of six, mom and five older children aged 16-23. They were dealing with the loss of their husband and father, who had actually booked the trip before he passed. 

Talking to different people on my tour was eye-opening and rewarding. We were together long enough to get to know each other some, and months later I still regularly communicate with many of the people on my tour. 

So do both! Enjoy the hassle free, responsibility free travel you get with a tour group. 

Enjoy the freedom of creating your own vacation. Tailoring your itinerary to your personal tastes and desires is incredibly rewarding. Just make sure to do your research, and put in the planning time so your vacation runs smoothly. 

Bon Voyage!

Tag: tour group

  • This Evil Happened in Pol Pot’s Killing Fields

    This Evil Happened in Pol Pot’s Killing Fields
    ,

    Another memorial for ‘Never Again.’ Genocides keep happening, following a similar blueprint.  Experiences over things. The mantra for my second half, because we learn. Some of my most influential experiences have been at places I’d rather not have to go. I’d rather they did not have to exist. Battlefields. War Memorials. Concentration Camps. Killing Fields.… Read more

  • Hop-On, Hop-Off Buses: A Great Way to See Monaco

    Hop-On, Hop-Off Buses: A Great Way to See Monaco
    ,

    Monaco is a perfect place to use the Hop-on, Hop-off bus; a different world that must be seen to be believed I have picked up a few habits while exploring our world. One of them is going for a long walk at dusk, without a plan or destination. Another is learning the local courtesy words.… Read more

  • Blue Jays Love to Find and Fight For Your Nuts

    Blue Jays Love to Find and Fight For Your Nuts

    Blue Jays are intelligent birds, and will chirp each other during a game of hiding peanut ‘Easter Eggs’  “Squawk Squawk! Squawk!” The grey and blue jays were making a racket over peanuts. A large grey jay had dropped the peanut hiding on the edge of a hanging flower pot, and was none too pleased about it. Red,… Read more

  • To The Ass Who Cut Down my Parent’s Sunflowers

    To The Ass Who Cut Down my Parent’s Sunflowers

    They weren’t just sunflowers. They were a tribute to my late wife, Ivana. The sunflowers grew tall, slightly bending to the wind that blew across the yard. Five majestic plants, radiating back the warmth they collected from the afternoon sun. They were the largest sunflowers I have ever seen, huge seed pods surrounded by the… Read more

  • A Final Road Trip With My Incredible Wife

    A Final Road Trip With My Incredible Wife

    Our last drive together, taking Ivana to her final resting place. Our final road trip together. Just us. I was taking my wife home to rest.  April 8th was Ivana’s birthday. A few weeks before, I learned that the mausoleum I was waiting for was finally ready. The marble for Ivana’s columbarium was at the cemetery.… Read more

  • Surfing The Violent Beauty of the Ocean

    Surfing The Violent Beauty of the Ocean
    ,

    Surfing rule #1: The ocean is in charge.  My surfing instructor explained the turtle roll thusly: “So when a big wave comes in, hold onto the board and roll. Let the wave go over the board and then roll back over.” I squinted my eyes into the sun, looking out over the incoming waves. “You want… Read more

  • Magic at the Rose Bowl: Michigan V Alabama

    Magic at the Rose Bowl: Michigan V Alabama
    ,

    A bucket list checked with an overtime thriller!! The Rose Bowl. A magnificent stadium hosts a game for the ages. The Tide stopped rolling on the three-yard line. The final yell of “Roll Tide” died on the lips of all the red and white wearing Alabama fans. The navy and gold clad Michigan fans outnumbered… Read more

  • Check Your Bar This New Year’s

    Check Your Bar This New Year’s

    Resolutions are cliché, and seldom make it to February. This is a companion article to ‘Keep Your Bar High: The Best Advice I Know’   New Year’s eve is fast approaching. A time to reflect on the past year, and look forward to 2024. We’ll think of things we can do a little better, or a lot… Read more

  • Our Journey Together: Giraffes Are Picky Eaters

    Our Journey Together: Giraffes Are Picky Eaters

    “Wake Up The Wild” at African Lion Safari reminds us that animals have colorful personalities.  “If you drop a carrot, do NOT pick it up! The giraffe will go after the carrot as well, and those calcium lumps on their head will absolutely knock you out if you bump heads.”  Our guide was dead serious,… Read more

  • Our Journey Together: ‘Moby Brick’

    Our Journey Together: ‘Moby Brick’

    Time well spent. Building lego together with Ivana produced surprising memories As I look back on our life together, I now realize how valuable TIME really is. Yes, family and friends time is wonderful. But we spend more time with our spouse than anyone else. When I look back on the time Ivana and I… Read more

  • Our Journey Together Part 4: Gorilla Parenting and Tiger Cubs

    Our Journey Together Part 4: Gorilla Parenting and Tiger Cubs

    The animals gave my wife and I wonderful memories at the Toronto Zoo. Michael Williams The gorilla children were misbehaving, and mom had seen enough. The game of tag between the young brothers had devolved into a hissing, spitting, and teeth baring match, while mom and dad had been chilling in the shade. Mom was… Read more

  • Our Journey Together Part 3: Three Fingers High

    Our Journey Together Part 3: Three Fingers High

    The First ‘Greatest Day’ of our Life Together A few times every vacation, there are moments of pure magic. Ivana and I shared many magic moments during our first big vacation. Planned in the blue folder, (read part 2) we were driving to Atlanta for a NASCAR race, then on to Florida for Disney and… Read more

  • Our Journey Together Part 2: Skip-Bo and the Moonwalk

    Our Journey Together Part 2: Skip-Bo and the Moonwalk

    Strange Acceptance Ivana and I would spend the next few days enjoying being together. We both knew her time was coming to an end, although our degrees of acceptance shifted both separately and day to day. Our moods, mine more so, would change on a dime, especially if testing or results were part of the… Read more

  • We Are All Vincent

    We Are All Vincent
    ,

    I am no art critic and have zero knowledge about painting. All I know is that great art makes you feel something special. Walking through the Van Gogh museum in Amsterdam, you get a sense of who he was. You feel his emotion in his work. You sense his anguish in every brushstroke. Read more

  • Our Journey Together Part 1: Tap Tap Tap

    Our Journey Together Part 1: Tap Tap Tap

    The moment I knew my wife was never coming home. It was a Monday. Nice enough for the beginning of March. A few large snowflakes slowly fell but melted as soon as they landed. I pulled up to the Royal Victoria Regional Health Center, put the SUV in park and hurried out.  We were not… Read more

Verified by MonsterInsights